We were thinking of adding an awning and possibly some fretwork around the veranda and eaves, but am yet to find something similar I like to see how it would look.

Perhaps something like this would work with the straight lines of your verandah railing http://www.hammersmith.com.au/hs_products/external-staircase-and-building-components/window-canopies-facia-trim-and-rosettes/ah001r-federation-canopy-treated-pine some verandah/eave corner brackets? Any pics to give a rough idea of what you like even if the house doesn't look like yours?

I agree with a window hood, and you could consider replacement the aluminium window with a double hung timber window which would enhance the proportion of the joinery. Also you could paint your fascia in a light colour with the contrast of the barge capping and gutters in the dark colour which would bring out the detail.

It appears various updates have been made without regard to original proportions or contemporary good looks.

The façade would look better balanced if the colour of the barge boards in left half of image was repeated in the other right half e.g. along leading edge of the verandah roof where any original guttering would have been more visible, I think.

That downpipe could be re-angled and repositioned so it is not so visible. (I paid to have this done after a non-consultative plumber gave me an ugly arrangement at the corner of a roofed deck.)

Was that front window originally broader? It looks out of proportion as it is. I'd like to see a broader, timber-framed window. Also, I'm guessing there would have been a gable above the window. And possibly a timber awning (depending upon aspect).

Front steps could be broader and better looking and have timber handrails.

I'd avoid decorative fretwork unless local houses that are of the same age and in original condition have decorative trims. It could look like a frilly add on.

Best wishes for whatever you decide.

In my opinion it's a great looking house. It just needs attractive "eyes". I agree that the aluminium windows are the problem. Replace the windows with timber and it will look a million dollars. Be careful not to go over board with too much tizzy federation (embrace the simple workers cottage), and take time to choose a window that suits the architecture. Maybe something like attached? You could consider enlarging the window on the gable end wall to a double bay. I would recommend slightly wider external architraves as well. Check out reclaimed building supplies yards.

I agree re addition of an awning. To me it would add the 'eyelashes' to the eyes. Changing out the windows for more architecturally appropriate ones would definitely be a plus if it fits the budget. You could also consider softening the space with a couple of column plants such as Lilly Pilly 'Pinnacle' (easily kept compact in width so it won't block your windows). See pic below to give you an idea of how it would look! Enjoy your beautiful home!!

Thank you so much. Makes such a difference.