Houzz Logo Print
motton_m

Advice tweaking final Floorplan

8 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

Hi there, I'm very new to Houzz, this is my first post and this is our first build. We're getting close to finalising our floor plan for a custom build in Gippsland, Victoria, but felt that we could get some honest, constructive feedback and ideas from the Houzz community by placing it on here. So here goes..... We have a young family, 2 adults and 2 children. Our block (893 square metres) is located at the end of a court. It falls from the footpath towards the bottom of the block. Our design has the house split level (working with the block), garage & master at higher level, steps down to remainder of house at lower level. Our vision and wishlist has been: - north facing living - 4 bedroom (1 guest bdrm) - triple garage (2 x vehicles + 1 x boat) with rear access - study (separate, but interactive to living/kitchen area) - rumpus - accessible from lounge (handy whilst kids are in younger years, whilst rumpus is a playroom), accessible to bathroom without going via main living area, accessible to the outdoor/alfresco area. Mindful that this creates many doors off the room! - built in gas heater in living (not on the same wall as TV) - WIR's for kids and master - lots of storage! Copy of our floor plan, and how it fits on our block below.


We're interested in feedback on: - the functionality/layout of the kitchen, ie. placement of door to WIP, fridge, sink, oven etc. - location of gas heater in living, should this be swapped with the sliding door to rumpus? - WIR sizes in kids rooms, are these a good size to utilise? - how we can make study more interactive, double doors, wall cut out? There is not external window, just a skylight, don't want to feel too boxed in working from home. Like the idea of being able to be interactive with the family at times and also be able to close off when need be. ie. study nook not an option. - anything else you can think of! Hope that we are on the right track. Cheers, motton_m

Comments (38)

  • 8 years ago

    AH.. My old school drafter hat on is spinning seeing those dimension lines overlapping and going through text and other elements, eek.. I would fail this drawing if it were my student.


    Anyways, only real comment I have to add is carpet in the Rumpus room? I personally wouldn't especially with young kids. And what storage solutions are you thinking of with regard to that room and toys etc.

  • 8 years ago

    I'm hearing you C R, the dimension lines are quite distracting!

    Thanks for your comments, we have since decided floorboards in the rumpus (with a rug) .... much more practical with the kids and adjoining the outdoor area.

    Storage, we're thinking a long low cupboard along the west wall under the window and possibly shelving. Possibly a tall cupboard along the wall backing onto linen too.

  • Related Discussions

    Double Storey Floor Plan Advice

    Q

    Comments (11)
    Hi Rozzi Klomp, I would not only increase the size of your kitchen, but I'd look at swapping your living and dining areas. The current layout looks to provide a very long and narrow living area (3 x 6m?). A great way to check how each 'space' works is to consider the furniture layout for the living and dining areas. This will highlight how each zone works individually, as well as how each responds/interacts with your views, the kitchen, and related circulation. Understanding how each space works individually, and together, will inform the shape and layout of your kitchen design. Considering this our suggestions are: Locate bench and cupboards along the wall backing onto garage (relocate laundry to garage 'store' area). This will provide you with additional storage and/bench space. It could accommodate the stove, wall oven, fridge etc. Increase the size of the island bench. This bench could be orientated to the view, or the dining area. This would depend on your preference for facing view or using the bench as 'gathering' space (cooking whilst preparing food and /or breakfast bar). Depending on the orientation of the central bench would it be better as an island or peninsular bench? Make sure you have adequate circulation within the kitchen (between benches/ joinery) and around the kitchen to ensure good circulation and function.
    ...See More

    Advice on a floorplan for a new build - Country Victoria

    Q

    Comments (19)
    Hi, Just a few quick tips to take or leave: -The nook will need some form of natural light & ventilation such as a skylight (you may already be aware). -You mentioned you wanted a slab on ground for thermal reasons. You would actually lose a lot of heat with an uninsulated slab on ground in Ballarat. Insulated underneath it and the thermal mass would be of benefit, but the general advice that a slab on ground will allow thermal mass to couple with the earth for a constant temperature would not work in Ballarat (unless you want it to be constantly cold) -Otherwise your plan has a lot of positives and you've put your thermal mass wall & fire to the north so you could also use it to store the heat from the sun via windows. I think there is a little wasted space which could be improved between the kitchen and N/E living area caused by the 'long & skinny' shaped living and island bench... Something which could be tweaked when you have your working drawings done? Or you could even take a metre out and push the kitchen/dining up to save some floor area (dollars) or add to other rooms.
    ...See More

    Advice on final floorplan for duplex

    Q

    Comments (5)
    Hi Kate108, The layout looks good to me. My only suggestion is, is it possible to somehow switch the stairs and the powder room / linen / laundry to improve the flow from the family area at the back - where most people will spend their time - rather than off the lounge room? If you had windows instead of French doors leading out to the atrium, how would you access that space? And would you need to access it on a regular basis. French doors do look great, but if you're concern is that they take up space, then could you go for a sliding door instead?
    ...See More

    Floor Plan Advice

    Q

    Comments (50)
    I really like that facade. Thank you so much. It is brilliant of you to take the time Siriuskey. I had reservations about our plan but through the knowledge and inspiration I have received from you Houzzers, I got some wonderfull ideas to enhance it that I can take to the draftsman and the ideas will improve it greatly. I have taken in the thoughts and ideas of posters. Some I've agreed with and others that I didn't agree with were still of great benefit because then I was able to fully assess what suited me and our family and tweek the suggestions. I am researching further and asap I have something to share, I will. Warm regards Wendy.
    ...See More
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Hi

    A nice new house. We're the largest cabinetry manufacturer in Asia. And also provide kitchen, wardrobe, bathroom, full house design, etc.

    Hope the following pitctures can bring your better ideas.

    Please see more info on our profile, thanks


    Full house interior design of American style · More Info



    Modern White Style of Whole House Design · More Info


    Neoclassical Style House----Living Room · More Info


    motton_m thanked OPPEIN Group
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago


    looks like it will be a lovely home my suggestions includes minor variations for ensuite and kitchen and perhaps the entry to master could be relocated to create an entry foyer and the wiw could be squared off to add extra to the entry hallway for waist height storage and gallery wall to give more interest to the long entry and wider stairs to the family room


    motton_m thanked oklouise
  • 8 years ago

    I was going to suggest oklouises pantry door position - to eliminate those annoying corner cupboards, a spacious pantry... perhaps use some of it to enlarge the store with its door opening to the garage?

    A good size garage, lengthwise, except dont have a long vehicle on the left without shifting the door northwards.

    Is the split level to minimise the drop at the back or just a feature? It could be a hindrance for shifting furniture and should one of you needs a wheelchair. Also you have room for a double door (for those reasons) and it'll look greater.

    There seems to be some wall at the side of the fridge, this restricts you or next owner on the size of fridge.

    Also all rooms a minimum of 2 power points, easier now than later to put in. & one each side of the beds - not central, which is awkward.

    Wishing you a smooth construction and perfect home.


    motton_m thanked brixnmorta
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Two's Company Renovations for your thoughts, comforting to hear your gas heater positioning confirmation. Ensuite door and fridge adjustments, and suggested large slider for studey are very helpful too. The privacy to bed 3 & 4 when accessing the toilet, bathroom etc has been on our minds, hence creating the alcove entrance off the rumpus. But, yes, it still isn't private if entertaining guests on the verandah etc. The extended passage down to those rooms is a good suggestion. We've been trying to avoid long passages where possible. Perhaps we'd need a window at the end of the extended passage to bring natural light in. Will give it some thought.

  • 8 years ago

    Wow thanks so much oklouise for taking the time to sketch out some variations, greatly appreciated. We've been tossing up moving the pantry door as per your suggestion, is the dishwasher ok there opening towards the end of the island bench (with appropriate width)? Really like your corner cavity slide suggestion for the study - thank you! The way you've re-jigged the ensuite also works well too. Thanks for thoughts regarding entry and long hallway, it has worried me that there's only the master bdrm door and a whole lot of walls in that hallway. Relocating the entry to master breaks it up, and gallery/storage suggestion could be a goer too. Really grateful for your time!

  • 8 years ago

    Hi brixnmorta relocating the pantry door sound like a positive move. Could also have a window at the end of WIP for more natural light too. Yes the store room could come across a bit more and become a "mud room" type entrance from garage, other door from garage into entrance hallway then wouldn't be required.

    Split level is all about working with the fall of the block, to minimise a high deck (and stairs to the backyard) and the need for privacy screens along the rear boundary fence. With your reference to wheelchair, did you mean double door at the front entry? All great suggestions re: power points too! Thanks again

  • 8 years ago

    Yes, a double front door would be ideal. It looks like you have a side window at the front, maybe have glass panels in the doors or above them to brighten the entry

    Your WIRs are good planning as well as the heater location.

    Re Twos Company passage idea, google highlight window, and maybe put one or two in there alongside the rumpus room. Add a door too as you wanted rumpus to bathroom access.

    Possibly a window in the pantry, but put tinting on it later if it heats the room too much.

    motton_m thanked brixnmorta
  • 8 years ago
    How exciting that you're building and it looks like it will be a beautiful place with good light.

    OkLouise's suggested layout looks ideal - particularly since it opens up the study more so that you could put in sliding doors as a feature, perhaps with some glass in the doors to allow light.

    I also agree with Two's Company Renovations on several points - particularly that it's not ideal to enter bedrooms via the rumpus room. I'd have all the bedrooms coming off a hallway so that people can easily access the bathroom without needing to enter a living/rumpus area. You may wish to have a skylight somewhere in the hallway though as it may be a little dark.
    motton_m thanked Rach P
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    these suggestions include the excellent idea for the mudroom, adds a sink & tap to the garage and eliminates looking directly at the toilet from kitchen by rotating the guest room (same floor area but places wardrobes next to ens for more privacy) enlarges study and relocates laundry bathroom with a central circulation area to break up the long hall, perhaps eliminating the need for privacy doors at either or both ends of the hallway...achieved by stealing 20cms off minor bedrooms.. the problem of dark hallways can be overcome with Solar Skylights (ie Solar Powered ceiling lights eg Arcol from Bunnings) )and/or panels of glass in walls above doors, panels of glass in doors and/or fixed or ventilating windows between external and internal rooms (eg between guest and study, entry hall and garage, pantry and garage) (minor discrepancies in my measurements are caused by ignoring correct wall thickness for simplicity)

    motton_m thanked oklouise
  • 8 years ago

    Hi there motton.m good luck with your build and your lovely soon to be new home

    OKlouise I have attached a couple of photos of my favourite cavity slide corner doors, you would have seen the 3rd photo on bathursthouse. apart from these Barns are very popular




    motton_m thanked siriuskey
  • 8 years ago

    internal sliders are an excellent option for many doorways especially where they can meet in a corner and be opened to leave no corner post to obstruct passage to motton's study area..

    motton_m thanked oklouise
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Exactly, I agree, that's why I suggested bathursthouse could use these corner sliders in his new build to open/close off the living/dining/family area from the entrance and bedroom wing, these would also be perfect for Motton's Study.

    The Japanese use this Shubui concept as walls to section off their houses which is brilliant.

    Bathursthouse received many great ideas from other Houzzers among them your excellent floor plans, it will interesting to see what he comes up with

    motton_m thanked siriuskey
  • 8 years ago

    Brixnmorta, the double entrance is a great idea, makes moving things in & out and as you mention possible wheel chair babies etc, also wonder why the split level, perhaps because of the slope but other wise all one level makes life easier. also pleased to see the corner pantry in the kitchen gone, I hate them.looks like you and your young family will end up great home..

    motton_m thanked siriuskey
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    siriuskey thank you for the corner cavity slide photos, they will definitely work perfectly in our study space. Admittedly we hadn't planned on building a split level home, but we weighed up either stairs in the home or the need for a deck with stairs in the backyard.....and much prefer the idea of no raised deck with stairs. Instead we'll have a low alfresco area (without hand rails etc.) that we believe will increase the feel of the backyard space (and interaction with kids), rather than separating it with a deck at another level. Entry to pantry greatly improved, pleased that it removes corner cupboards too!

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks also to many of you for your preferred suggestion to have the bedrooms and bathrooms both accessing a hallway (rather than via the rumpus) for privacy. This is very much noted and it's been on my mind, I've been trying alternative layouts, whilst trying to avoid a passage all the way to the back of the house!

  • 8 years ago

    Just an amateur photo of my cutting and pasting.....moving kids bedrooms allows access to toilet and bathroom within existing passage. Laundry and guest bedroom are accessed off the rumpus instead. Negatives with this though are that my insistence on having WIR's results in kids beds up against the ensuite and toilet walls.....! So not entirely ideal.

  • 8 years ago

    here's some variations for bedroom access...(rough measurements need to be further refined depending on which variation you might prefer)


    motton_m thanked oklouise
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    how about this one with wiws


    motton_m thanked oklouise
  • 8 years ago



    hi there, the split level makes good sense with easy access for the kids playing outdoors. I was just looking back at your original plan and thought that with having a young family it would be better to swap the laundry/bath to have the kids bedroom together and moving the guest room to Bed 4, and then I noticed your last post suggesting this, I personally think that would really work. Would it be possible as Brixnmorta thought to have access to the garage via the kitchen even possibly combining the Mud room and laundry into this area, ie; using some of the rear of the garage with a door giving access to an outdoor clothes drying area. the following photos of a kitchen and laundry divided by a sliding was done by a Sydney Designer in a Federation house in Willoughby Sydney. Who wouldn't mind doing laundry here. cheers

    Tailored Interior · More Info


    Tailored Spaces, Clever Layout · More Info

    A contemporary shaker style kitchen · More Info

    motton_m thanked siriuskey
  • 8 years ago

    Like OKlouise 3rd drawing with the Bedroom next to study but perhaps remove the WIW and replace with a wardrobe at the other end of the bedroom so that the WIW space would allow for separate WC plus another in the bathroom. Would prefer laundry else where though. I think 3 toilets is a good thing in a 4 bedroom house, especially when you have guests. cheers

    motton_m thanked siriuskey
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thanks again oklouise for the designs, my preference is for the 2nd version. Yes siriuskey it seems the laundry is not fitting well along this side of the house. I love the design and images that you've added of kitchen/laundry, both ends look to have external doors and natural light which is a huge plus in that design! We could revert back to an earlier version of our plans where we had the laundry/pantry at the rear of the garage (behind the kitchen). It has been altered somewhat since, being that the home is now split level, the back of the laundry/pantry wall would have to lineup with the end of the ensuite/WIR wall of our current floorplan. (snap shot of previous laundry/pantry idea below). The reason we moved the laundry near to the bathroom was to steal a bit more backyard space on the entertaining side.....

  • 8 years ago

    oklouise your 3rd version works well with the bathroom, WIW, WC combination. Just not keen on internal laundry as I'd really like it to have an external window/door.

  • 8 years ago

    With the previous laundry/pantry design (as above) we were leaning towards the door to garage being via the laundry, rather than the WIP.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    i haven't yet fully investigated the laundry near the kitchen but searching for solutions i found this idea with a saving of about 10 sq m and keeping the childrens' WIWs. It's such a great house with very generous rooms but, if you're happy with the slightly reduced bedroom, there might be other savings that could further reduce costs, contribute to the quality of finish and the size of the backyard


    btw if the laundry was near the kitchen would you want it at the same level as the kitchen or the garage and where do you see the best place for the clothesline without interferring with the drive through from the garage??

    motton_m thanked oklouise
  • 8 years ago

    Hi there, I have sketched in what could be possible keeping everything on the same level as the kitchen. I have taken from the kitchen laundry photos I posted for you and extended the kitchen sink wall right across into what would be the laundry, this would have a window/glass door installed for light and access to clothes drying, with a sliding door to close this area off as per photo. The Pantry would also have a sliding door access next to the steps, the bench in between would still house the cooktop and Fridge. Oven?, this could be installed in the island as I have in my house, I have the cooktop above that in the island,. something for you too consider.

    Oklousie changed the shape of your entrance this area could take the place of a mud room for putting down stuff when either entering via front door or garage.

    Does your property have water access or is the roller door just there to access the yard, perhaps this door could have some clear panels for light.

    Your Rumpus & guest bedrooms a good future potential to become a granny flat for a parent. It would be great to have access to a toilet and shower from there, It's only money





    Concord Green Home · More Info

    motton_m thanked siriuskey
  • 8 years ago

    Garage door with see through panels to light up interior space, this one is very glam.

    We have neighbours with a similar entrance door, not as tall though, they then have a shoulder height stud wall set back forming the entrance, this gives light & views through the other rooms while keeping the privacy, it's a lovely home.

    motton_m thanked siriuskey
  • 8 years ago
    We lived in a house with stairs to allow for the fall of block! I always wished we had made them wider. Ours led from kitchen eating area to rumpus room/2nd living area so different from yours. The other aspect to keep in mind: are the properties on each side also sloping and will you have any overlooking from them. Try and stand on your block and visualise where your windows and outdoor areas are then look at next door. A small window to provide light into pantry is good. Can be high up if preferred.Use Viridian Eco glass to avoid heat. Good luck I am in my 16 th house!
    motton_m thanked zoelayla
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    This is a good way to get light into room while saving wall space


    making the house split level could change the outlook from the living spaces, I'am sure Motton has considered this.

    High glass panels/windows above the the cook top area would certainly give light into the pantry/laundry.

    Re the stairs a bit of extra width could possibly be gained from the study area?


    motton_m thanked siriuskey
  • 8 years ago

    despite many attempts i haven't found a successful laundry near the kitchen without compromising something else and attempting to satisfy all wishes and suggestions this variation has the children's bedrooms (with WIWs) and study with private hallway access to the family bathroom and separate toilet (with sound insulation) The laundry and guest room open either directly or through a short hallway from the rumpus and there's an optional guest bathroom (granny flat, teenage retreat?) for easy access from the rumpus, deck or outside Most external windows and doors have been excluded as these should be determined by outlook but this plan fits within similar footprint to the original house although at around 400sq m perhaps some extra size reduction may be necessary

    motton_m thanked oklouise
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    John & I have just been looking back on your 2 x plans and congratulate you on a great design. we also agree that the split level situation makes placing the laundry into that area unlikely.

    I have tried to do a bit of cutting and pasting as you did to try and show what we think could really work, The current position of the WC doesn't work as when the door is open that's what you will see from the family room, annoying.

    Move the new bathroom/toilet layout next to the Ensuite and behind the study, then the Laundry which could have an external glass door and a sliding pocket door which would throw light back into the Family/Passage, then place the 3 bedrooms next to each other, you would have to do some tweaking of these to fit. Would still have loved a small ensuite in the 4th Bedroom.

    Just one other thing that I keep coming back to is the placement of the fire place, I think it looks out of place and could be moved to a side wall, making the opening between Family and Rumpus cleaner.

    Would you also consider doing stacking or large sliding external doors that come together as per the study on the Family/Rumpus room, we did this with an internal courtyard and is brilliant.

    A copy of our current 70's house which is beautifully full of light all day due to high windows, they should have been opening to allow through ventilation, we're working on that. the kitchen now has the bench and half wall removed and now has a large island bench



    motton_m thanked siriuskey
  • 8 years ago

    Wow oklouise and siriuskey you are both incredibly generous with your time and suggestions. So many great points continue to be highlighted, for which we are ever so grateful. I've printed it all out and we'll have a good look through it together and be in touch..

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks so much zoelayla we're on the right track as we've taken a ladder to the block and placed it on the tray of a ute to see our full outlook and view! We'll definitely be widening the steps (thanks to oklouise) and yourself, and pantry window tip is very helpful. Congrats on your 16th house - what an achievement!!

  • 8 years ago

    Good luck with the build.

    motton_m thanked zoelayla
  • 8 years ago

    Sorry but I would sack the draftsman. He/shes no architect. That roof is a nightmare. I try and think about the function of each room and how you would live in it. The entrance is like a cricket pitch but no where to put the bat and ball when you are finished. You come in from the garage or entry door and you are in the middle of nowhere.. Where you going to put you shoes and jacket. And if you want to use the toilet or wash your hands went you get home you have a 20m trek through the house.?? Don't like the bedroom 1 right at the front door and the doors are all hung wrong. You are going to be walking around them all day. The ensuite is badly sized. Shower to narrow, toilet too long and no basin. You going to be opening that door with dirty hands. Think about the floor space to dry your self and dress/undress. Cavity sliders are a pain. Like you have to open them almost all the way to get through where an opening door you glide through. With cavities also you mostly have to walk into the corner of a room to get in and out (study and rumpus) where as a normal door it 1/2 a step less. Master bedroom walk-in wardrobe is dumb. Draw it on the ground, work out how your clothes will hang, and see how much room you have left. Same for the bedroom 3 and 4 wardrobes..Dumb. What were you thinking with that pantry.. It like 8 steps in then 8 out again. Pantry should be more square, have a butlers sink in it. Be the food prep area, pots dishes etc out of sight especially in an open plan place. Be light and the food perpetration area be close enough to the door so you can converse with the guests or family other wise you might as well have a maid who is not seen or heard. Bed 3 and 4 are miles away from a bathroom. The toilet is probably OK in size, just needs a bigger door. 720 you are going sideways through it. Bed 2 backs onto the shower and toilet. Which room are you going to put your little kid in. Long way from mum and dad.

    motton_m thanked accra
  • 8 years ago

    Well Motton M there's some tweaking points to think about and add to your list before your final plan is formed. Just one thing from this is that I did want to ask about the Roof, and what style you had planned for your new house, the split level could add $'s to this. I think we're all going to be waiting on your response to ccra. Good luck with that x


    motton_m thanked siriuskey