Hi There! It is a great idea but not practical for resale. How much space do you have? Our team help consult me how to maximise the value of their property through renovating for profit. We are not interior designers, we are property professionals who understand what it takes, and passionate about creating a nice space to come home. We'd love to help! If you are interested, feel free to drop us an email: hello@interior-motive.net :)

am i correct in understanding that this space has no windows and will be a wiw and entry from the living areas to the master bedroom? do you plan to have enclosed storage (wardrobes with doors) or open shelves, what do you need to store eg clothes for how many people, lots of ball gowns and multiple shoes or mostly jeans and shirts, clothes for various seasons, or only tropical as well as christmas trees and suitcase and secret stuff...start with what you need to store and work backwards and excellent lighting (daylight, skylight or electrical) will make all the difference for success

the doors into the living area may be fashionable but limits furniture placement in both living areas and bedroom but, if you're confident that there's enough space for furniture the French doors could feel more open but, perhaps you need to wait for comments from NYC residents for local ideas...your dilemma has been posted in Australia where styles may be different

I think it depends on how neat you are in keeping your hanging clothes looking nice. Some walk-in-robes have the aesthetic of a tornado hitting a 2nd hand clothing store. You have three "dead" corners in your proposed walk-through robe which are always tricky to access clothes. For a walk-through robe I would always prefer two opposing rows of built-in cupboards with nice doors and door hardware to avoid any potential mess. At the end of the day it is your home, and it is your private sanctuary so it has to be right for you and I wouldn't care about "tradition". So many "traditions" in building design are about saving builders costs, and not about good design for the way that you live, which is the most important thing. Best of luck with your considerations, Dr Retro of Dr Retro House Calls/Dr Retro Virtual Visits.