Houzz Logo Print
joanne_simic

Stumped by stairs

Joanne Simic
6 years ago
Hi all, we have initial plans drawn up and i can't seem to wrap my head around the stairs , hoping for some advice for the stairs & if any other suggestions for the house plans please go ahead , greatly appreciated.
U shape stairs, Pros: can move garage 1 door to end of entry for more space to move in/out , top level when enter you walk into space and views . Cons : bulkhead at enrty doorway as otherwise you will be able to see the stairs , top level walkways between kitchen & bed areas 1100 .
L shape stairs , Pros : no bulkhead at entry, top level walkways between kitch & bed aeras 1600 . Cons : garage 1 entry door , top level as you enter you see a wall then views .
house slopes 4.3 upwards from street , balcanys & views to east , bedrooms side is north . end of court block 767m . I hope this helps & have given enough details . thanks Jo .

Comments (65)

  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Your house plan looks to have just about everything, what a man cave, it's to die for.

    I would like to see the stairs arriving into the living room with that view and light thrown down into the stairs, rather than climbing the stairs and looking at a wall.

    With an open railing beside the stairs to allow for more light and making that space feel more open and bigger.

    What is next to the sink? the sink looks like it's squished into the corner perhaps it would be better to position it on the long wall along with the cooktop cheers

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    thanks Siriuskey , ideally the top level entrance i totally agree with you, the sink/dishwashing from corner not back wall is 1800 so not to squished . maybe different kitchen layout could incorporate the entrance so no bulkhead at entry doorway garage level , without changing too much floorplan top level ?
  • Related Discussions

    What type of plants

    Q

    Comments (16)
    Be aware that artificial turf can get very hot underfoot. You could lay a narrow old brick or limestone paver path to clothes line for easy access and plant ground covers or low profile herbs (eg.oregano and thyme) to use in cooking. Hardy herbs or flowers such as rosemary, lavender, geraniums against the edges of the space toward the back. Even add some large long troughs of flowers on the retaining wall to pretty up the area. It looks like it could get quite warm there but maybe a jasmine or similar climber to climb up a frame attached to the part of the large wall where there is no clothes line. Good luck, it will be a lovely space I'm sure once you get started.
    ...See More

    Want to add to a heritage house? Thought of using a removal house?

    Q

    Comments (65)
    Thank you so much for your kind words, everyone. Houzz never ceases to delight, I am so glad I began this renovation even though it was an incredibly stressful journey at the time!! Here are a few more pics taken over the last 2 years.
    ...See More

    Help, our lounge/dining room is just not working.

    Q

    Comments (10)
    I'd consider putting the corner sofa and TV stand in the dining room, moving the stand-alone chair and footstool and tall lamp near the stove as a "reading nook" and placing the dining table in the living room, leaving enough for a walkway from the entry to the current dining / possible living room. In terms of the actual furniture, everything other than the colour of the dining chair fabric looks pretty good. I would start by decluttering and removing anything that isn't functional or which you don't find aesthetically pleasing. I'd personally remove the mirror in the bar as I don't think it gels very well, the tiny framed art near the stove, the art on the wall near the TV as it's too small and hung too closely and the drum kit (unless the drum kit is used on a daily basis). I really like the Marimekko print and, IF you like it, then I would use it as inspiration for adding colour to each of the rooms, possibly even a "feature" wall using the bright blue from the print (although I'm not a huge fan of feature walls). A few minor changes may also help, like replacing the blown bulb in the wall sconce, storing the ironing board somewhere else and taking down the "hanging" glasses in the bar area as they're visual clutter right at eye line height.
    ...See More

    Renovate or Knock down rebuild?

    Q

    Comments (20)
    I'm just trying to work everything out , and what happened when basically . The front seems quite nice , but I'm trying to work out the original floorplan -- I'm wondering if it was originally a 2 bedroom cottage , with the left side of the house ( looking from the front ) as a lounge and maybe kitchen/dining behind , then an outhouse ? Looking at the pictures and the floorplan , where the kitchen is now is in part of the fibre cement 'addition 1' ? It doesn't look old enough to have had a lower kitchen on a concrete slab -- that slab was generally a step down , and often on one side or the other , but I guess it could have been at the rear , but then it would have been likely to have been in brick too . You say the kitchen is 'falling to bits' ( well , not quite ) -- basicaly , I did wonder about 'just' recladding the rear , maybe demolish the rear lounge and laundry and rebuild that , maybe a bit bigger/deeper , and maybe even step it down , so then you could have sliding doors and a larger terrace , even if it is 150mm lower again ( I'm not a fan because of trip hazards , but some designs are better than others ) . BUT to throw a spanner in the works , how about demo the rear , rebuild kitchen/dining/lounge/terrace 30 or 40cm lower , maybe even on a concrete slab , BUT do a couple of bedrooms and family room/office/master and ensuite / whatever upstairs ? Or maybe 2 more bedrooms , ensuite , bathroom , powder room , study , laundry , whatever you want downstairs , and then kitchen / dining / lounge / family upstairs to get the views ? Basically , a character front and modern rear , maybe match some design elements -- I know you've said a forever home , but value wise in your area you'd probably get your $$$$ back and more -- only problem is it won't be cheap . Its like saying that $1 million painting is sure to appreciate -- thats good in theory , but if you can't afford to buy it , it doesn't overly matter haha .
    ...See More
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    What is that on the end of sink base cabinets?

    I've just measured our passage in our open plan house and it's just under 900 and works really well, why do you think you need 1600. Sorry the bulkhead you mention is that a wall to conceal the stairs, can you sketch.

    Should the downstairs Bathroom be linked up with the entrance, this would be a much nicer larger space, and better access to that bathroom from both the house and garage, you could have doors on both sides.

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    hi , the end of the sink is the dishwasher & the passageway doesn't have to be 1600 thats just how it works out with the plan so far , yes the bulkhead is to conceal the stairs above the main entry And no not sure if i can sketch, ha ha not very tec savvy, im surprised I've managed this . your bathroom idea in garage area sounds like a good idea , would you be able to sketch to give me a better understanding, thanks you very much .
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Sorry that's the down stairs passage @1100.

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    same , just has worked out like that .
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Just starting my computer to do it, it hot and slow like me at the moment

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    ha ha , i know the feeling
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Here is the idea, leaving you to consider doors to garage and bathroom to work with the stairs. But I think it's a good idea to include this bathroom in the house, with a powder room available for the desperate rushes cheers


  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Just wondering why not an open staircase in timber?, it would certainly make the entrance look and feel bigger.

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    ohh i like this idea, the desperate toilet rush lol , certainly does happen & also great for the older generation that travels to visit .
    i like the idea also of the open staircase , i am still hoping to incorporate a landing in the stairs for safety, older & younger , will have a look further with this garage bathroom idea & see what we can come up with . you have been a great help . Thank you.
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    could a staircase start beside the toilet turn right and then right again with landings at both points?

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    hmmm another option, you guys are great , i would have to have a look and see how it would fit in with the kitchen upstsirs, i think rough calculations are 4.5 m for about 17 stairs & then add on 800mm for every landing . thanks .
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Oklouise could draw that for you my stair skills still need honing Ha

  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    I have just played with the stairs



  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    thankyou siriuskey, this is similar to the original plan which i like the concept, only unless my understanding is wrong ( which most likely) won't you as you open front entrance you see the stairs going up above your head , hence bulkhead needed . ?
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    The underside of the stairs above the entrance doorway can be gyprocked to look like the ceiling, and the other sides of the staircase open to the entrance (how high do you have that second landing at

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    oh thankyou, the roof height is 2700 then i think its 400 above that the second level will start . beams etc .
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    That's a very good storage space under the stairs next to the front door?

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    yes , you never can have enough storage so ive been told , especially when hubby also loves his garage time & can never let rusty old crap go . lol .Im pretty sure your garage idea is going to work , so thank you very much & i should be able to make the stairs work in the space as well with not too mich compromise on what we think will work . do you have any pics that could represent the open stair L shape look . ?
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Now that you have that extra length in the entry, you could have a lovely side board/table with a large mirror or art work above it, it would really make the entrance look special.


  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    this will give you an idea of what the entrance could look like with walls or not wall colours aren't a good example but should give you some idea cheers


  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    thanks for your time , i obviously have to see things to get a better concept of how things work , i think i want to have more clean lines and space as you enter , so will make the L shape stairs work somehow with the bathroom in the entry . you have been a great help .
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Just keep in mind that with L shaped stairs you only get one landing to break up the length of the stairs, L has a long and a short, where as U shape has two landings which shortens the length of stairs to make them less of a fall hazzard cheers

  • oklouise
    6 years ago

    there's not enough width to have the two 6m wide garages and stairs with a double landing without sacrificing the position of the kitchen which is already only 2m wide and overlapping into the living area...although there's usually enough "leftover space" for some storage under the stairs, the best way to understand the stairs is to forget the leftover space and have exactly the same space upstairs and down and then add a hallway width where you want to get on and off the stairs (hopefully with access to other rooms as well).....what is the width of the block and the required set back each side and is it possible to reduce the width of the long garage at the rear?

  • siriuskey
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    The list of measurements given say that the kitchen is 2500? and garages 6 & 7 meters wide, the stairs take up some space from the 7m garage. The passage is a whopping 1400. the kitchen Island can/could be changed to suit the large lounge as shown By moving the sink & DW to the back wall or into the Island which could then be moved across into the kitchen space

  • oklouise
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    several HOUZZERS have suggested northern living areas so here's a reversed variation with option to add some northern windows for winter sunshine... i've included structural support for the front balcony with a covered entry porch, a simple gable roof and a few other variations and you could also consider raked ceilings with scissor trusses for the living areas


    and a view as you reach the top of the stairs..the red chair is beside the fireplace in the living area although the blank wall directly in front needs a gorgeous artwork and small hall table

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    thank you oklouise, this plan looks great , some great ideas to go forward with and discuss options with hubby . do you guys like updates ?
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Yes please, I still prefer the other entrance which includes the powder room as it makes a more open entrance which is important for such a big house, The entrance?stairs and powder room should all be included in the one rectangle

  • oklouise
    6 years ago

    obviously we're obsessed so updates are always welcome and the extra hallway downstairs is to separate the bathroom from the foyer and allow the caveman to move between garages without having to go through the formal entry

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    ahhhh decisions decisions, It's all so exciting , I will definitely keep you guys updated , i love all the enthusiasm & all the helpful ideas , its a relief to know im not the only one obsessed .
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Yes please I still like the other entrance which includes the powder room, it's more spacious which is what you want for an entrance. You would need to go with the "L" shaped stairs. can you re check the measurements

  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Love your house, we also live at the end of a cul de sak and love it... very much looking forward to what you and hubbie come up with

  • oklouise
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    my obsession comes from realising that plans are the most important part of the build and this is the cheapest time and method to test ideas and it's very disappointing to discover there could have been a better way when it's too late to change...another critical issue is that this is a very big house and it would be useful to consider which variations might save money without losing the best of your design (eg my suggestion for the structural support under the front balcony and accessing the same balcony from the master creates a roof for an entry porch downstairs and omitting the front balcony off the master gives unobstructed views from the master and a loo with a view but??...make a list of good and bad for every detail so you don't include anything that won't be a vital part of your new home

  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Did forget to mention that some of the Garage space will make great future Accommodation for extra income/teenagers or a Granny flat, with already having a bathroom it's perfect.

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    yes, i was thimking along the same lines for the future but not sure if it would work because the garage will be dug into the block a bit & not much natural light will get in , but in saying that once we finalize these initial plans we can then look at the elevations & the rest & see what happens , Its hard because im trying to get what we need and want now with the way we live & budget but then also thinking towards the future to accommodate our needs & wants with maybe with a little extra in the bank to make some changes for our lives .
  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    It's good to have a plan and don't forget that the garage doors can be replaced with windows etc, might be worthwhile looking at garage doors with windows in them for helping to get more light into the garages

  • PRO
    Paul Di Stefano Design
    6 years ago

    To get this (all) resolved, fundamental aspects need clarification. Firstly, site conditions/data - accurate data about the boundaries, neighbouring context, and levels. These are critical constraints that can be creatively exploited and negotiated. Secondly, the desired requirements and some idea of the client priorities. 2x double garages that is creating a squeeze on the residence entry is arguably imbalanced spatial resolution, but ultimately that's something for you guys to work through in regards to what "wins" as the priority over the other........... I'll let you in on a (trade) secret. You best don't design outside in, (but you need to know/establish detail to be able to) ..... Rather, flip it and work from inside out and enable the building form to be malleable until further down the track........... It's like here you've got a whole heap of it "locked in" and then upon review are stuck on the stair which have been left to resolve until after other things and then trying to get it to work with minimal room to move or flexibility.......this plan, unresolved to your particular satisfaction reflects that the design process taken has missed a critical aspect and hence fallen short - "so close, but so far" if you know what I mean........So what to do? I would say/suggest that further info/ understanding the site conditions/context would be helpful.......First thing i do when designing? get the critical information sorted. First "lines" put down? if it's a renovation you get the existing conditions established and super accurate. New build (like this one) - you start with anything relating to the brief requirements as in HOW the spaces are to be used ie dining table, lounge, sinks, vehicles etc....and get the relationships working in context.....the LAST aspects to lock in are the walls, after fit-out, after windows....Why do it this way? Because you get (spatial) outcomes that are relevant/customised to (a) context and (b) specifically client brief needs/choices/decisions and it forces deep understanding and working through the individual and collective function and relationships of the various elements and not just popping in a space of XxY dimensions to (maybe) suit a particular need. This way maximises/balances efficiency and also the potential of the living experience/quality of the home......it may seem more complex doing it this way, in a way it is but in another it is actually easier because you have more flexibility/options available to achieve certain requirements...........if you really "need" 4x car widths across the front then that's your call and I'll never tell a client what they should or shouldn't have.....but I will endeavour to understand inherently how they wish to live and clarify what is more and less important before then moving forward with making critical dimensional and spatial decisions on various scales/details/levels.......the point I'm making is that you can achieve certain "functions" with arguably infinite various, but you have other aspects that you cannot budge. What design does is deal with the relationship between these two - It is naturally a bit of a juggling and shuffling exercise and an organic process that too often (I see) is simplified to a linear process that results in imbalance and arguably missing opportunity/potential on the value/quality of the overall end result........you've got a fair amount worked through here that you are happy with which is great. But looking at this from an experienced perspective, upper layout of the living/kitchen/dining could be thrown around/flipped/freed to get a much nicer stair/entry set-up, as well as some rationalising of that rather generous and (arguably unnecessarily restrictive) lower level set-up......A house of this scale shouldn't feel tight ANYWHERE, particularly not the entry and at the moment the scaling of the main spaces are out of whack..... and that's the (sometimes dirty/gritty) process - push/pull, give & take....not straight forward, not black&white or right & wrong and ultimately requires a compromise and understanding to find that balance....exactly like marriage yeah ;)

  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    Totally agree that the entrance needs to be something more important "the promise of things to come". I have already suggested that the downstairs bathroom be included in that space and shown that. The kitchen does need to be looked at to work better within the space and could be moved across the room or just a re work.

    How wide is the upstairs passage 1400 x 13800, 1400 is extremely wide

  • siriuskey
    6 years ago

    I relate this house to a Queenslander built on stilts etc and the under house was used for cars/caravans/laundry/WC. They would have both an internal access and exterior. Any site plans to share?

  • PRO
    Daniel Lindahl Architecture
    6 years ago

    I haven't read through all the posts so this might have already been covered, but you would also need to consider the clear space you need to provide over the stair - 2m minimum height above stair nosings.

    With the U-shape it looks like you have room for some kind of storage cupboard opposite the bathrooom door upstairs. If you pushed the stair back into an L-shape that cupboard would disappear, and the clear space requirement might even encroach on the fridge space.

  • Janelle
    6 years ago

    Have you considered utilising a local professional building designer to achieve your dream home? Money well spent, to create a functional home that you will enjoy living in.

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    yes we will be catching up soon , looking forward to sharing our updates . thanks .
  • PRO
    Paul Di Stefano Design
    6 years ago

    Ha! Spot on Janelle - this is (sadly) a general problem/issue in the industry and community......so often we see on these forums people struggling with a problem and throwing out the question/dilemma to the general public for help to solve. We then have suggestions/opinions/answers thrown into the mix which may or may not be relevant/helpful and then people are left not necessarily closer to resolving.....and partly it's due to missing critical information/data.......A floor plan is not just a particular functional arrangement of spaces/walls/doors/windows etc.......it (should be) a representation and resolution of a person/couple's/family's home living experience at a particular place/site. To do this it involves multi-layered balancing of "wants/wishes" against available/viable budget within a particular physical context. Without understanding this, it is reduced to a hit or miss process for people trying to wrestle with it and sort it all out for best result on their own - to achieve true value for money (for the project investment the upfront design resolution involves problem solving underestimated in it's complexity, which generally, a professional will be best positioned/experienced to guide/assist with...

  • Janelle
    6 years ago

    Yes Paul, I have worked in the Building design field, and know the process well. How easily a wonderful residence can designed that reflects the client's personal style, ticks all their needs boxes, be built to budget, and has low running costs. Be designed to suit the site, etc. etc.

    If you employ a good designer you won't need to be losing sleep over how does my stair function. Money well spent for long term enjoyment.

  • oklouise
    6 years ago

    we've successfully employed professionals for many different projects but the problem has always been that we first needed to understand what we needed (to suit our climate, lifestyle, structure and budget) because when asked that question there's no free time to consider lots of different options ...the professionals can usually make good suggestions and refine our ideas but sometimes we need to fantasize about a range of different options to discover that some things are just not possible, affordable or realistic and that's where HOUZZ can offer the opportunity to test out lots of ideas so homeowners can have a better understanding of themselves before they employ a professional ...and, it's always good to see the professionals offering simple practical suggestions along with all the amateurs

  • Joanne Simic
    Original Author
    6 years ago
    thank you oklouise, that was my understanding of this forum, we will be engaging in the professional next week , with some new, extra & great ideas to put forward for our wants, needs etc that you guys have helped narrow down . happy to post updates if any one is interested. Lots of opinions which is great & appreciated & my theory is that you can take out of it whats helps you & suits your own personal needs & wants , you might not have thought of something that someone suggests .
  • oklouise
    6 years ago

    we look forward to seeing what you discover, best of luck to you

  • PRO
    Paul Di Stefano Design
    6 years ago

    yes oklouise, I hear all that - absolutely yes it's all about clients understanding/working out properly what they need.........and it's great to be able to seek comments/thoughts on Houzz from a broad range of backgrounds/experiences......the issue though is when it gets into territory where (from my perspective) clearly experience and professional skill will help resolve the problem most effectively (such as on this particular one) that it's therefore appropriate to suggest this the advised way to go.......I suppose I see frequently here capacity for designers to be able to "cut to the chase" most effectively, but of course this needs to be done in a manner underpinned by a thorough understanding and establishment of what the client needs in context, and yes very often the client will require more time to work this all through.........I however still see our role as relevant in that part of the process though, and not necessarily having to "wait" for that to happen, because ultimately as professionals in this position (i believe) have a responsibility (as part of our role as a consultant) to educate people appropriately and thoroughly so they can develop the skills to be able to consolidate their decision-making most appropriately for themselves and the project - by the end of the journey, I find my clients are rather quite the experts!..........this however involves a collaborative approach, egos are shelved and an intimate working relationship, which is very different from the approach (that some designers work to) which is essentially selling a "product" or particular end result, rather than a service....significant difference, and again, horses for courses ;)

  • oklouise
    6 years ago

    thanks Paul, we need supportive professionals and clients need better understanding of the processes