I did post it in Design Dilemma, but I am not sure if it did load it.

Hi! Looks incredible. What paint did you end up picking?

A personal favorite of mine, your gothic revival facade is eloquent! I'm not sure if you were asking for actual help painting this, or whether ou wanted advice on maybe colour choices etc. I can offer my opinion on colours to start the conversation. To further enhance the brick corbelling around the sill line, and other horizontal banding, I would go with a similar dark tone, so the brick detail blends seamlessly into other architectural details. Unifying the most impressive elements in single application of colour keeps it looking classy and avoids becoming fussy. Distinctive exteriors such as yours benefit from a simple and sympathetic colour palette. So use the buildings colour palette and build on that. Brick corbelling was to accentuate the horizontal plane, and ran thought detailed window bays, and extravagant entry sets, helping draw your eye around the entire facade. So using a colour tone, perhaps not too dissimilar form the dark brick itself, would really make them stand out even moreso. Something like a woodland grey would link into the slate roofing also, and is still a coloured grey, with a browninsh undertone to it. It works well with established foliage, and most styles of architecture. Good thing in that you've already seen what white highlighting does to it, now I'd go down the other path, and darken the trim work, so he cream brick detailing becomes more prominent on the window arches.

Unfortunately white is not just white any-more there are so many whites. As the grey you have selected is a "medium" grey not to light / not too dark. I would go for a crisp clean white. I don't have any names but I would not go for a white with any slight tinting. Make both colours strong in their own right.