The black leather sofas are the ones we currently have, but the modern one is in the family room. The antique one is currently in formal lounge, but we are not necessarily planning on keeping it… I am so complicated, aren't I :(

here is one that might work I dont think all timbers need to match exactly and that some contrast can actually help (*not just colours that are close)

Modern and contemporary but with well crafted materials and textures such as timber and stone to add warmth and character to a space. It is also important to be site specific and enhance this.

Embrace what you already have! It's far easier and more successful, I really can't stand 'faking' eras! And you've got a great little base there to bring the life back into! Depending on what you like you can have a lot of fun and make it look really stylish. - For something more fun, go a cute 50s paint colour wiht fresh white trims e.g. a celadon green, a duck egg blue or a happy yellow if you're brave! Add some great plantings (look up Palm Springs for some great ideas). - or for more classic and stylish but still in keeping, you could go monochrome fresh white, charcoal or even a beautiful maritime blue, add some natural timber/wicker to stop it feeling too stark and maybe some smart stripe (black or navy & white - or even bold yellow or green?!!) fabric awnings will also help the facade looking too flat, Check out places like The Atlantic at Byron Bay for great inspo. - I personally love this look. - or if you like a look more eclectic again looking to hotels for reference, check out Halcyon House - white, besser/breeze blocks, vintage cane, but layered with lots of texture and pattern mainly around a fresh indigo blue & white palette. What a great project, you can have a lot of fun with that little place, and if you're unsure, ask here!