Houzz Logo Print
webuser_351794580

Design Dilemma: 20m Wide Lot with Massive 10.5m Tree Setback - Build F

last month






Hi Houzz community, looking for some design wisdom on a unique block we've just committed to in Perth.

The Lot:

  • Size: 20m wide x 30m deep (600sqm).
  • Orientation: North to rear (perfect!), South to street.
  • Constraint: A mandatory 10.5m front setback due to three mature, protected River Red Gums.
  • Elevation: The lot sits about 1.2m - 1.4m above the street level.

The Dilemma: We want a single-storey family home (4x2 or 5x3) but are torn on the best layout strategy to maximise the North-facing rear aspect.

Option 1: The "Wide & Shallow" (Keep the Setback)

  • Stick to the 10.5m setback line.
  • Build a wide, horizontal home (approx 18m wide x 12-13m deep).
  • This leaves us with a 7-8m deep North-facing backyard.
  • Pros: Maximises the backyard depth we can get.
  • Cons: The house feels "squeezed" into a narrow depth.

Option 2: The "Push Back" (Use the Front)

  • Push the house further back (maybe 1.5m from the rear boundary).
  • Treat the massive front yard as the main garden.
  • Pros: Huge front garden space (shaded by the gums).
  • Cons: Sacrifices the North-facing rear privacy and winter sun benefits? Harder to secure/store things in a front yard?

Questions:

  1. Has anyone successfully used a front yard as their main private open space with low permeable fencing? How did you handle privacy and security?
  2. With the lot being elevated (1.2m+), does that give enough natural privacy to make a front living connection work?
  3. Is an L-shaped or H-shaped design the secret weapon for this 20x20m building envelope?

Any layout ideas or photos of similar projects would be amazing!

Comments (103)