Houzz Logo Print
jodie_narik

Different coloured stone benches – anyone done this?

Jodes
5 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

Hi Houzzers,
Has anyone done different coloured stone bench tops? Eg island one colour, other benches another colour.
I am contemplating having our island beach in the white with veining stone and the other benches behind it in the dark charcoal.
This is just to save some $$. But I’d love to see other kitchens that may have done something similar to see if it looks ok.
The cost saving is $2k, which in the scheme of a house is not that much but I guess every penny counts?? Or should I just keep with the white everywhere?
My vision was to have quite a white kitchen but with dark overheads, white cabinetry under the benches.
Thanks



Comments (43)

  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    Bump
  • zaffa
    5 years ago
    Hi Jodes, I have seen lots of kitchens with different colour stone benchtops, say on island and peninsula. Looks great and can break up the sometimes clinical feel of all white kitchens. I guess the stones need to match. Are you sold on the white stone pictured? The vein is very prominent and I wonder if a more subtle veining, day like a Carrara, might blend in more with a different colour stone. What will be the feature? Just a thought.....
  • Related Discussions

    Vinyl floor for the whole house-anyone done it before and any regrets?

    Q

    Comments (6)
    Thanks LesleyH. It's music to my ears since our place is on concrete. Of all the houses listed on Domain, I'm yet to come across one with vinyl flooring for whole house or most part of the house, so it's still bugging me a little. Went into carpet court last weekend they use vinyl display on their own shop floor and there are a lot of gaps between vinyl planks, which doesn't look enticing. The salesperson explained this is due to poor floor prep and the site is prone to water issue, which as tenant they can't fix. Certainly not a good look to convince potential buyer.
    ...See More

    Has anyone used YDL stone for their bench in “Rosemee”?

    Q

    Comments (1)
    Is this the one? I think it's quite cool toned and will complement your grey/white bathroom nicely
    ...See More

    Will having 2 different benchtop colours work in my kitchen?

    Q

    Comments (16)
    Hello dear, I believe it is to choose and arrange colors to match existing furnishings, or possibly in some cases to even choose furnishings as well to give a certain 'look' to a room or rooms. But, an interior designer is someone who plans, researchers, coordinates, and manages such projects. An interior designer evaluates and designs interior living and work spaces to make them functional, appealing and well-suited to an owner's needs. Interior designers make interior spaces functional, safe, and beautiful by determining space requirements and selecting decorative items, such as colors, lighting, and materials. Recently I have done interior design in my office from HTS Interior Design LLC, who offers an interior solution to meet specific needs from concept design to turnkey Fit Out solution.
    ...See More

    Island bench and side benchtops - should they be the same stone?

    Q

    Comments (7)
    stone in kitchens is an easy surface to have in a high traffic zone - The Marble Man repair, polish and seal stone surfaces - when you make your final decision have a think about the wear and tear of the bench tops - give our office a call for our professional stone services 1300 627 626 | The Marble Man
    ...See More
  • Angeliclee
    5 years ago
    I agree with Zaffas comments. A more subtle stone would work better. I have to different stones and they work, however they are away from each other and are to separate zones - kitchen has Smartstone Carrara and butlers pantry and wine bar have Silestone Kensho.
  • Renai Habets
    5 years ago

    Or if your heart is set on the heavy veining, perhaps a lighter rear bench to match the vein colour?

  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    Thanks for your replies.

    We are reasonably set on the Grande Statuario Quartz (White with veining) as the white is lovely and crisp and we love the contrast of the dark veining. The whiteness is the closest match to the white cupboards which will be underneath. Every other brand seems to clash with the crispness. The tops end up looking really warm and yellow nec to the cupboards (they are Lexicon 1/4). Neither of us want marble or speckled looking tops.

    The house has a lot of contrasts, crisp white walls (Lexicon 1/4) with bluestone feature and timber floors. Dark charcoal carpets in bedrooms.

    The little chip is the overheads colour. It goes really well with the veining and the dark stone. In real life to me they go well. We could look at something lighter.

    The kitchen is a feature in the house. But I like the idea of the island being the hero.

    One stonemason has mentioned he isn’t confident about being able to match the veining. Online it says they are book matched, so ‘should’ line up. The other stonemason hasn’t mentioned any issues with joining them. Our island is almost 3.2mt long. The slabs are 3040mm so will require a join. The carcasses are already built so cannot change the size.

    I’m feeling a bit stressed about this. We are owner builders so don’t really have anyone to help us with colours etc. We’ve already been to stonemasons twice to look at various brands/colours. They’ve done 3 quotes for us. I don’t want to keep wasting their time.

    I’ve posted a couple of pics of the look I’m trying to achieve with the Grande in some of them.

    Thankyou
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    Apologies for one big paragraph.

    I’m on my phone so it seems to ignore all spacing that I put in!!
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    I would love to have just a plain crisp white top along the back benches but I can’t find one that is crisp enough.

    They all look good on Pinterest but when you put the samples together it doesn’t seem to work.
  • zaffa
    5 years ago
    Have you seen absolute Blanc by Smartstone. Or Caesarstone pure white?

    Have you had a look at the Stone Ambassador range? They have similar stone with veining that is 3.2 long. This would save you a join which would be my preference


    https://www.stoneambassador.com.au/ranges/trinity/
    https://www.stoneambassador.com.au/ranges/statuario-signature/
    https://www.stoneambassador.com.au/ranges/sierra-leone/
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    Thanks Zaffa. Hadn’t seen them although one of the stonemasons mentioned the brand. He said the warranty wasn’t quite as good.

    We had chosen Absolut Blanc initially but when put next to the white paint it looked terrible. Our walls and cupboards are just too crisp.

    It’s too late to change the white as the kitchen has been painted as well as the house.
  • zaffa
    5 years ago
    It’s a 10 year warranty. I have a mix of Caesarstone Smartstone and stone ambassador in my place and the quality is the same. A friend of mine has lexicon for her kitchen and walls and her stone is pure white, Caesarstone. It’s so hard matching whites and even harder (I think) as an owner builder. We have just come out of a 3.5 year owner build and never again!!
  • zaffa
    5 years ago
    Also remember that when the stone is horizontal it will attract more light and look whiter compared to the vertical cupboards
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    Zaffa would your friend be happy to show a pic of their kitchen?

    I’ll check out Stone Ambassador.
  • zaffa
    5 years ago
    I just contacted her and my mistake. Her cabinets are Wilsonart Parbry vinyl doors in Frosty white Matt and her stone benchtops are Alaska from CDK Stone in Richmond
  • zaffa
    5 years ago
    Jodes I do think you should seriously consider having a larger size slab to avoid the join. I agree with your stonemason that it will be hard to match the veining to look natural. You always have a fine white join line that will be obvious next to the veining. And it will be hard to work out where to put the join. You will also need to buy 2 slabs at a minimum and possibly more if you want the waterfall ends to also match where they meet at the mitre. So more expensive too. In my opinion bookmatching a stone benchtop does not look like the veining has a natural flow. Just my opinion.... hard decisions to make.....
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    Quantum Quartz do an Ultra White. Have just received the sample and it’s lovely and crisp...

    It looks good next to the wall colour (also cabinet colour) but it’s on the $$$$$ range.

    Stonemason is coming to the house this arvo. Will have a chat.
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    Well I think we'll go the Ultra White.

    Looks good next to the white cabinetry. It should look seamless.

    I'm a bit disappointed we can't do the veining over the island but I don't think we would be able to find a slab big enough so there's no join.

    Photos of the kitchen carcasses. Cupboards under bench are lexicon 1/4. Overheads are the charcoal timber grain.

    Looking at the island with window behind, it will be the dark charcoal underneath.
  • zaffa
    5 years ago
    Good choice Jodes. Did you not like the Stone Ambassador Slabs as they are large enough for your island??
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    Hi Zaffa
    No, they were too grey and marble looking for our liking.
    Hopefully it comes up how we picture it and isn’t too stark!!
    So many decision!!
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    5 years ago
    I’d still have to have a join with the Ultra White! The slab isn’t big enough for our island ☹️
    Our island is about 3110mm long. Back to the drawing board!!!!
  • The Doktor
    4 years ago

    Have you considered Glass Fibre Reinforced Concrete (GFRC) bench tops ?


    They can be coloured from white, through various shades of grey to black and should be easily able to cover your island length without any joins.


    We had ours done last year in GFRC and the manufacturer was able to mould the island top and waterfall as one piece so no join for the waterfall.



  • Jodes
    Original Author
    4 years ago
    Elizabeth that is stunning!!

    What did you use can I ask? I think I have finally gotten to the point of deciding on Aurea Stone. Either Spirals or Sequence and using it on all benches. The slabs are 3200mm long so I won’t need a join on the island.

    Now I’m back to wondering about that back bench being a contrast. It might be too much though as our overheads are quite a dark colour.
  • Elizabeth Wilson
    4 years ago
    Thank you - we love it. We used Quantum Quartz porcelain for the long bench and splash back. We managed to get the splash back from the second piece. On the other benches is also Quantum Quartz stone in a Cement. It’s got a very small fleck through it. What I love about both is that the matte finish is so easy - doesn’t show finger marks etc like high gloss and don’t need to dry it after wiping down.
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    4 years ago
    Quantum Quartz Grande Statuario is our favourite but the slab is a tad too short so I’d have to have a join on the island. I’d rather avoid this so that’s why I’ve leaning towards the Aurea Stone products. They come in a silk finish which is just beautiful. But the Grande is still my pick but I think the join would become noticeable as time went on with dirt.
  • Elizabeth Wilson
    4 years ago
    The Quantum Quartz porcelain was 3200 long but our bench was 4 metres. Nothing that long so we didn’t have a choice about join
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    4 years ago
    Could you take a photo of the join so I can see it?
  • Elizabeth Wilson
    4 years ago
    Here it is. Would prefer not to have one. Probably more obvious on the marble due to the various colours
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    4 years ago
    Yes, a solid colour would be easier to hide I imagine.
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    4 years ago
    Elizabeth did you use one of their 6 or 12mm porcelain sheets rather than the stone? I saw them on their website last night. No pics as being used for benchtops but the sheets are long enough I wouldn’t require a join if they’re strong enough.
  • Elizabeth Wilson
    4 years ago
    Have to use 12mm for benchtops - 6mm not strong enough. We were going to use 6mm for splashback but saved some money by using the excess of the second sheet which fitted nicely. You may have already done so but if not, suggest you visit them so you can see full sheets - that was what finally decided us.
  • ellaboss12
    4 years ago
    Hi,
    I’m an interior designer and kitchen specialist,
    I would never design with a join in an island. It’s a shame the cabinetry has been made. Designers will design to slab sizes for this reason it looks better and will save you money. Choose a larger slab. The join won’t look good.
    If you do have a join be very careful of the stone company you go with and make sure you see their work. Some companies leave up to 4mm joins and don’t colour match the join properly. Not all stonemasons are the same.
  • Elizabeth Wilson
    4 years ago
    Yes, I wouldn’t design a kitchen bench with a join either but we inherited a kitchen layout and didn’t change it to save money. The join is only noticeable in our bench if you are looking for it.
  • Jodes
    Original Author
    4 years ago
    This is what I’ve decided on. Aurea Stone in Spirals in a silk finish for the island and splash backs with Quantum Quartz Ultra White on the back benches. In most lights the stones match well. I will have to have a join on one back bench but this is unavoidable due to the length of the bench, I have avoided a join on the island which was my main concern.
    We designed the kitchen ourselves. We’ll know for future if we ever build again!
  • Elizabeth Wilson
    4 years ago
    It will look beautiful. I think kitchens are very personal and you should have what you love
  • Susan Vale
    4 years ago
    I can't see the other comments for some reason but I have seen heaps of kitchen photos on Houzz featuring a white island bench and dark benches. They look good - just search modern kitchens.
  • Isla
    4 years ago

    I wouldn't go those dark laminate kitchen cupboards. I have the exact same and I absolutely loathe them now. I use to love the darker colours but now I wish I had just done them white, light gray or even the dark blue (although dark blue worries me a little too!). That dark laminate brown is such an absolute pain to keep clean. They show up every mark. I like your stone bench tops though but would look at other options to create the look you're hoping for with the joins and waterfall benches etc. Goodluck with it all!

  • Sarah P
    4 years ago

    Hi, I know this is an old post but do you mind letting me know where you sourced Aurea stone from? I’m in Sydney so hoping someone here supplies it... also do you know how it compares in price to say smartstone or quantum quartz? Thank :-)

  • Jodes
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Our Aurea Stone went in today and I LOVE it! We contacted Caroline at Zen Stone in Melbourne. She might be able to help with suppliers.

    We contacted our local supplier after we found the Aurea Stone. I put them in contact with Caroline.

  • beachcombing
    4 years ago

    Well done Jodes. It looks amazing. Yes, lots of decisions, but I bet you are pleased. Wow.

  • pascoeyvonne
    4 years ago

    Your kitchen looks great! All your effort in putting it together has been worthwhile!

  • PRO
  • PRO