Pros & Cons: Kitchen Islands
Experts make the case for when adding a kitchen island is a good idea, and when it’s not
Mitchell Parker
13 March 2019
Houzz Editorial Staff. Home design journalist writing about cool spaces, innovative trends, breaking news, industry analysis and humor.
Houzz Editorial Staff. Home design journalist writing about cool spaces, innovative... More
These days it seems as though every kitchen you see has an island. But these built-in features aren’t for everyone, or every kitchen. Here, two US-based designers – Joanne Cannell and John Nichols – weigh the pros and cons of adding an island and consider whether creating a kitchen without an island might be better for your space and lifestyle.
The case for kitchen islands
Arguing for: Joanne Cannell
Expertise: “I am a certified kitchen and bath designer practicing residential kitchen and bath design since 1990,” Cannell says. “After taking a number of design classes, I worked for full-service remodelling firms until I started my own design firm in 2001.”
Why she’s for kitchen islands
“If a kitchen is wide enough for an island and can’t have an efficient work triangle or sufficient work stations and work triangles for multiple cooks, an island can be the best option,” Cannell says. “If there won’t be sufficient counter space but clearances or budget are a bit tight, a movable cart or island could be the best solution. A cart also keeps an island from making the kitchen look cramped.”
Arguing for: Joanne Cannell
Expertise: “I am a certified kitchen and bath designer practicing residential kitchen and bath design since 1990,” Cannell says. “After taking a number of design classes, I worked for full-service remodelling firms until I started my own design firm in 2001.”
Why she’s for kitchen islands
“If a kitchen is wide enough for an island and can’t have an efficient work triangle or sufficient work stations and work triangles for multiple cooks, an island can be the best option,” Cannell says. “If there won’t be sufficient counter space but clearances or budget are a bit tight, a movable cart or island could be the best solution. A cart also keeps an island from making the kitchen look cramped.”
On an extra work surface
The main benefit of a kitchen island is the additional countertop space that can be used for prepping and staging meals. Working on an island can sometimes be more pleasant than working on a perimeter countertop where you’re facing a wall. An island work area allows you to face guests or family members while you prep, or feel connected to people in adjacent rooms if you have an open floor plan, Cannell says.
The extra surface also can be used for eating or doing homework, depending on the clearances.
Browse through images of kitchen islands
The main benefit of a kitchen island is the additional countertop space that can be used for prepping and staging meals. Working on an island can sometimes be more pleasant than working on a perimeter countertop where you’re facing a wall. An island work area allows you to face guests or family members while you prep, or feel connected to people in adjacent rooms if you have an open floor plan, Cannell says.
The extra surface also can be used for eating or doing homework, depending on the clearances.
Browse through images of kitchen islands
On extra storage
An island creates an opportunity for hardworking storage depending on how large of a base you can create. Deep drawers, cabinets and even a spot for the microwave free up the need for perimeter cabinets, allowing you to instead have open shelves or a window.
On creating another location for a sink or a range
An island can offer a location for a main sink or prep sink if perimeter space isn’t available or ideal. For the same reason, an island can be good for a cooktop, although in general Cannell tries to avoid this situation because of the difficulties with providing adequate venting.
On focal points
By introducing a base colour that’s different from the perimeter cabinets, or a countertop material different from the perimeter, you can use an island to create a dramatic focal point.
An island creates an opportunity for hardworking storage depending on how large of a base you can create. Deep drawers, cabinets and even a spot for the microwave free up the need for perimeter cabinets, allowing you to instead have open shelves or a window.
On creating another location for a sink or a range
An island can offer a location for a main sink or prep sink if perimeter space isn’t available or ideal. For the same reason, an island can be good for a cooktop, although in general Cannell tries to avoid this situation because of the difficulties with providing adequate venting.
On focal points
By introducing a base colour that’s different from the perimeter cabinets, or a countertop material different from the perimeter, you can use an island to create a dramatic focal point.
On closing the gap between work areas
“A kitchen can be too small for an island, but in a medium to large kitchen, wasted space and longer distances between work centres are often solved by an island,” Cannell says.
“A kitchen can be too small for an island, but in a medium to large kitchen, wasted space and longer distances between work centres are often solved by an island,” Cannell says.
On visual clutter
“An island can sometimes visually weigh a kitchen down or make it appear too cluttered, but colour choices and having some openness, such as for seating or a selected display of cookbooks or serving pieces, can alleviate visual weight and appearance of clutter,” Cannell says.
On resale value
If you need another reason to like kitchen islands, consider their popularity. If you add an island, you can feel confident that, should you sell your home, other homeowners will see your kitchen as a selling point.
Here’s how a kitchen island can be more than an island
“An island can sometimes visually weigh a kitchen down or make it appear too cluttered, but colour choices and having some openness, such as for seating or a selected display of cookbooks or serving pieces, can alleviate visual weight and appearance of clutter,” Cannell says.
On resale value
If you need another reason to like kitchen islands, consider their popularity. If you add an island, you can feel confident that, should you sell your home, other homeowners will see your kitchen as a selling point.
Here’s how a kitchen island can be more than an island
The case against kitchen islands
Arguing against: John Nichols of KitchenLab
Expertise
“KitchenLab has been designing kitchens for 15 years, and our work has been featured in many national publications,” Nichols says.
Why he’s (sometimes) against kitchen islands
“We aren’t against kitchen islands per se. We use them in clients’ kitchens all the time,” Nichols says. “However, each kitchen space is unique in terms of what can be done and brings a different set of challenges and inputs from the client and home. Particularly when we work in older homes in the city, space can really be at a premium, and some kitchens are better served without islands. Some kitchens work better with a peninsula, for example. It just depends on how the space works best.”
Arguing against: John Nichols of KitchenLab
Expertise
“KitchenLab has been designing kitchens for 15 years, and our work has been featured in many national publications,” Nichols says.
Why he’s (sometimes) against kitchen islands
“We aren’t against kitchen islands per se. We use them in clients’ kitchens all the time,” Nichols says. “However, each kitchen space is unique in terms of what can be done and brings a different set of challenges and inputs from the client and home. Particularly when we work in older homes in the city, space can really be at a premium, and some kitchens are better served without islands. Some kitchens work better with a peninsula, for example. It just depends on how the space works best.”
Nichols and wife Rebekah Zaveloff, a designer at KitchenLab, says they don’t have an island in their Chicago kitchen. “Our space constraints meant using a kitchen table – admittedly at island height – was better,” Nichols says. “We are able to push it aside and use the kitchen as a workout room or yoga studio – we don’t have the space elsewhere! This becomes a de facto dining room table as well.”
On cost
“Islands, for all of the function and structure they bring to a kitchen, are immovable and provide limited flexibility,” Nichols says. “They must have electric and, potentially, plumbing added if there’s a sink. Islands add a layer of cost to a project, which, depending on the clients’ needs, isn’t always necessary.”
“Islands, for all of the function and structure they bring to a kitchen, are immovable and provide limited flexibility,” Nichols says. “They must have electric and, potentially, plumbing added if there’s a sink. Islands add a layer of cost to a project, which, depending on the clients’ needs, isn’t always necessary.”
On taking up floor space
“Many clients feel they need an island,” Nichols says. “A smaller kitchen often makes this wish a non-starter. It’s better to have a kitchen that functions well with a table or peninsula, or neither, like a galley. All function perfectly well if designed carefully and thoughtfully with the clients’ needs in mind.”
Check out these space-saving galley kitchens
“Many clients feel they need an island,” Nichols says. “A smaller kitchen often makes this wish a non-starter. It’s better to have a kitchen that functions well with a table or peninsula, or neither, like a galley. All function perfectly well if designed carefully and thoughtfully with the clients’ needs in mind.”
Check out these space-saving galley kitchens
On visual weight
“We feel that giant islands that dominate spaces and have huge expanses of stone are fairly pointless,” Nichols says. “The space in the centre becomes useless. Using an island as a dumping ground for stuff is a battle in many families. Mudrooms, desk areas and designated ‘drop zones’ go some way to solving this issue. However, in our own home, it is a constant battle to keep the kitchen table clear. One solution to not visually weighing down the space is to do a freestanding, furniture-style island that doesn’t have fixed cabinetry.”
“We feel that giant islands that dominate spaces and have huge expanses of stone are fairly pointless,” Nichols says. “The space in the centre becomes useless. Using an island as a dumping ground for stuff is a battle in many families. Mudrooms, desk areas and designated ‘drop zones’ go some way to solving this issue. However, in our own home, it is a constant battle to keep the kitchen table clear. One solution to not visually weighing down the space is to do a freestanding, furniture-style island that doesn’t have fixed cabinetry.”
On traffic paths
“It comes down to proper space planning and programming the clients’ needs,” Nichols says. “You don’t want to feel like a hamster in a cage going around and around your island. If appliances and storage needs aren’t laid out properly, this could happen.”
“It comes down to proper space planning and programming the clients’ needs,” Nichols says. “You don’t want to feel like a hamster in a cage going around and around your island. If appliances and storage needs aren’t laid out properly, this could happen.”
On the temptation to go too big
“I think that, particularly in huge kitchens or kitchens that are in huge open-plan homes, the temptation to create a ‘landing strip’ of an island is hard to resist,” Nichols says. “There is no real point in this, however. There are great ways to design around having too much space.”
Read more:
8 Super Useful Kitchen Island Storage Ideas
Tell us:
Are you for kitchen islands or not? Tell us in the Comments below.
“I think that, particularly in huge kitchens or kitchens that are in huge open-plan homes, the temptation to create a ‘landing strip’ of an island is hard to resist,” Nichols says. “There is no real point in this, however. There are great ways to design around having too much space.”
Read more:
8 Super Useful Kitchen Island Storage Ideas
Tell us:
Are you for kitchen islands or not? Tell us in the Comments below.
What are you working on?
Related Stories
Renovating Advice
How Do I Find, Assess & Hire the Right People for My Renovation?
Do you need a kitchen designer or a joiner? An architect or an interior designer? Find out with our essential reno guide
Full Story
Renovation Guides
What Key Measurements & Room Dimensions Should I Know for a Reno?
Read practical information about key room measurements and minimum clearances for fittings and fixtures in every room
Full Story
Kitchens
How Practical Is... Handleless Joinery?
Handleless joinery is popular in modern homes. But how suitable are cupboards that can only be opened with a touch?
Full Story
Most Popular
12 Decorating Tips to Make Any Bedroom Look Better
By Anne Ellard
Want to know how to make your bedroom look better? Here are 12 great tricks
Full Story
Renovation Guides
Room by Room: Experts on Ways to Avoid Common Renovation Blunders
From the kitchen to the garden, and all areas in between, experts identify common mistakes and share priceless insights
Full Story
Interior Design
The Golden Rules of Proportion: Decor Laws You Need to Know
An interior designer reveals the essential rules for achieving a perfectly balanced interior
Full Story
Most Popular
5 Reasons Your Bathroom Smells Funky (and How to Fix the Problem)
A plumber reveals five reasons your bathroom might smell like sewage or emanate a musty odour
Full Story
Most Popular
From Planning to Pendants: Kitchen Lighting Essentials
By Joanna Tovia
This valuable guide will give you all you need to know about choosing kitchen lighting for fabulous form and function
Full Story
Most Popular
The Full Picture: How High Should Your TV Be?
By Matt Clawson
We look at an important question to consider when locating your television: how high should you set it?
Full Story
Bathrooms
All the Dimensions You Need to Know for Your Bathroom Makeover
Fit everything comfortably in a small or medium-size bathroom by knowing standard dimensions for fixtures and clearances
Full Story
I was not a fan of islands but understand their appeal. But the kitchen in my first home had no counter space for cooking and prepping food. I was on a bit of budget and did not have many options to expand. I bought a free-standing Island with a butcher block top and it worked very well. My latest home has more counter space but I find that my aging back and the counters are a bit uncomfortable. Im tall so I tend to have to bend a little to get things done. Prepping food is just not good. I’d switched to prepping seated but that is no better. I’m glad I held on to this small island when I moved because it’s come in handy as the height is more comfortable. It’s also now on wheels so it’s only in place when I need it and shifts out of the way when there’s one person cooking and another cleaning. Would I love to have something more permanent, yes but I’m not sure I want to rip out my kitchen cabinets to get it. I am a fan of these cabinets as they were built in Nappanee Indiana and are very good quality. Not a fan of peninsulas but I have one. If I could remove that and figure the cabinet without getting ripping out the remaining cabinets I would be happy. Would I use a cabinet maker for that? Any ideas?
I'm in love with this island
My problem with islands is you have to walk around then to access cabinets on the other side (if you don’t have an open space). I’m remodeling my kitchen a load bearing wall would be on the other side of an island. I’m not going to remove that wall so I’m going to use a peninsula to increase my work space. This will also allow me to tighten up my work triangle.