The other showers throughout we are just keeping the same tile with the niche so wanted to change this one up seeing as it's a big niche and make more of a feature of it. Am thinking a herringbone type tile or even small hexagons but it's more colour that I'm not sure about. A lot of those tiles are marble like colour The style of home is contemporary/Scandic if that's even a style ha ha!

last resort, check with local powder coating companies to see if they can paint some standard silver trim to suit

If you have the time I would fix it. Tiling, etc. (& bathrooms in general) are expensive and its almost impossible to fix down the track when you get sick of looking at it.... you will look at it every time you have a shower and say to yourself, why did I not just fix the bloody thing!

Look at what shampoo bottles you use and size accordingly. I know we have 2 pump bottles pls bath liquid and a couple of extra it,es for individual needs.