While i have no opinion on which is better product, can i warn against textured surfaces in a kitchen. They are very difficult to clean particularly on kitchen cabinets. Our old house had texture, very challenging, new house has ultra smooth glossy doors. Love them. Also they were perfect for our very dull, dingy kitchen as they reflect the light instead of absorbing it. Good luck with your project.

Laminex (who retail Formica) also have a similar finish called Riven- It is a textured timber look melamine. We have not heard anything untoward about the substrate, it is generally just a MR MDF, a standard board that all laminates are pressed onto. This is the Laminex range-

http://www.laminex.com.au/products.php#!/walls-and-panels/impressions-textured-surfaces-panels/riven-finish/view-all