Paint the cabinets or just replace?
We have this house under contract.
I love the house. It's old, stately, tons of character...but I don't love the kitchen. There's nothing particularly wrong with I, and I know it's probably someone's style...but its not mine. I feel like I doesn't fit the rest of the house at all. It's too dark. Too ornate. Too heavy. The finishes are too modern and mismatched the the rest of the kitchen. Etc. It just looks disjointed to me with the varying cabinet heights, and everything thats going on. Also, even though it looks like it has a nice big range hood, it's not vented to the exterior, so it's essentially a glorified microwave type of vent. Womp, womp.
That said, the cabinetry, though not my style, is custom and cost $20k (owner provided receipts). I kind of feel bad wanting to come right in to paint them knowing that, but I really don't like them as is. This house is a reasonable distance to a cabinet factory outlet, where I purchased what would be custom plywood box cabinetry, but was misordered, over ordered, etc. for our last home, painted it,and it worked out wonderfully and was less expensive than buying the unfinished builder grade press wwod box cabinets at Lowe's. The only thing is I don't REALLY want to jump right into a new house and tear the kitchen out and put more money into it right off the bat- maybe in a year or two.
What do you think, wise Houzzer's paint the cabinets without guilt, or just replace?
Comments (20)
cloudpants
8 years agoRelated Discussions
How can you tell if you can hand paint kitchen cabinet doors?
Comments (1)are they made of wood or mdf if so. they can be painted...See MoreKitchen - what should I paint? Floor tiles, cabinets, counter
Comments (16)Hi , I did a major repaint of my kitchen when I moved in last year (this is the second time I've done this in a home). From salmon pink doors and tiles with plastic pink handles, it has transformed into quite a lovely kitchen with crisp white benchtops and doors, retro aqua blue splashback tiles and chrome hardware. I didn't paint the floor tiles because it is not a good idea, it won't last. And I think in your case, the kitchen floor will not look as bad when you take care of the cabinetry and countertops (and appliances - don't forget the sink, this made a huge difference to my kitchen which had a horrible stained "white" fibreglass sink and plain tap). The only regret I have is that I was convinced instore by a staff member to use water-based enamel on the countertops and this was not a good idea as it marks and stains at a feather's touch and I am always scrubbing it with magic erasers to bring it back to white. Just use oil-based enamel, preferably gloss, and it will clean up beautifully. It will just yellow in about 5 years' time, which isn't an issue if you're not using crisp white like me. Step 1: remove all handles etc. and sand back the melamine/formica surfaces and vacuum up all dust. Wipe down all surfaces with methylated spirits to remove any other dirt and - especially - oils. Step 2: Undercoat all surfaces with White Knight Grip Lock Primer (keep this stuff on hand, it is magic and can be used for a million things). Give it two coats preferably. Step 3: Paint doors and cabinetry with a good quality high gloss acryclic. You can use oil-based enamel too, but it's easier to work with acrylic. It doesn't really scratch unless the cat tries to jump up above the cabinets and claw its way back down when it misses - in other words, don't run knives or screwdrivers down the doors and they'll be good. If it scratches, get a small artists brush and touch up with your leftover paint in the tins. It takes two seconds and is as easy as to do. Step 4: paint the countertops with an oil-based enamel. Clean up with turps. Do two coats and use a good quality brush. Give it a good few days to dry, a week is good if you have the time as it hardens in this time and becomes very strong - so put your camping gear and laundry sink to good use during this time! Step 5: put on new handles and hardware, install new sink and appliances and enjoy the makeover. For the tile splashback, follow the same steps, making sure you give them a good sand. You can use gloss acrylic here too. It will scratch if you knock it with a sharp object, but again, keep the touch up paints and a small artists brush handy. In your case, because the splashback doesn't go all the way up, I'd also consider chiselling the tiles out out and using a panelled splashback from somewhere like Ikea or Bunnings or a store that orders Laminex panels. They can be pretty cheap, and although not perfectly beautiful are a lot more attractive than those tiles. If you can save the tiles (the tile glue is probably old and brittle) and sell them, someone will love them on ebay! And even re-tiling with some cheap/chuck out tiles isn't difficult or expensive in that space if you are at all handy. Splashbacks in burnt orange or red would blend with the cream and floors. Other alternatives for the countertop (particularly if you don't want to patch up the gaps from the older, larger stovetops and sink) is to put in an Ikea or Bunnings (or similar) cheaper benchtop. I have also tiled a benchtop before and this worked really well with the added benefit of being able to put hot pots straight onto the benchtop. Don't use low end wall tiles. Use a stronger tile so they don't crack. Again, with your oh so brown floors, if you stick to lighter colours for the cabinetry (eg. antique white or cream) and a more sandstone-ish colour for the benchtops (or match the cabinet colour to the benchtop so you don't have to paint it and set off with the coloured splashback), the floors won't look as bad. Also, you can put a floor runner along the length of the kitchen hallway (in front of the oven/fridge area) if everyone in the house is generally steady on their feet and don't tend to trip over everything and this will break up the brown beautifully and you will barely notice the tiles. All in all, it cost me about $200 for the paint and equipment plus handles, sink and big shower tap, but it has meant that I am delaying my kitchen reno for a number of years, as I really like the kitchen now and everyone comments on how great it looks. None of this is hard to do. As a female, I have no problems doing all this myself as long as I have the time from work. But my father was a painter for 40 years, so that's why I can get the scoop on the best paints etc. to use on these projects. Good luck! PS: Don't let anyone tell you to whack some fancy paint on the doors and it will be done in a jiffy - it will peel off. Sand and grip lock prime - this is essential if you want it to look good longer than a couple of months....See Morereplacing kitchen cabinet doors
Comments (2)@kate, there is a thread started by a lady called Natalie. I tried to tag you in it. Sorry OP to jump on your thread. Need Kate's crayons....See MoreReplacing vanity unit, adding washer/dryer (thinking in a cabinet)?
Comments (7)Hi Kate, I'm yet to measure it up or see if any tiles are under vanity (settling next week). The property has an outdoor laundry (under the house) but would like to have this inside. Thinking if the washer/dryer is more centrally located (rather than in corner) it might be OK. Hopefully it can be done....See More
PROCarmen Darwin for Evolution House
8 years ago- PRO
Carmen Darwin for Evolution House
8 years agoThe other thing would be to have a builder add a bulkhead from the ceilings to the cabinets so there is no space at the top. Looks way better however you would have to replace the cornice too so depends on budget.
Farmers - Showcasing designs built & designed by Joinery Group NSW · More Info 
emilyam819
8 years agosmit2380
8 years ago
Lisa G
8 years agoKayla Thomas
8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
flopsycat1
8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago
PROJAN MOYER
8 years agolast modified: 8 years ago- PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
8 years ago Kayla Thomas
8 years agosmit2380
8 years agojbtanyderi
8 years agojbtanyderi
8 years agoKayla Thomas
8 years agoJust sharing a couple more pictures a friend sent me. Turns out her husband did some work on the house, and he had these pictures. I wonder when they added the other billion corbels. :P
nwduck
8 years ago
lefty47