Thank you for some concrete information. Those samples could actually be different batches of the one colour. The flecks and shading are almost identical. Is the new version the low silica option following legislative changes? If so, you’ve been caught up in a change that was beyond the Manufacturers and your control. It would also explain the same name being used, something typically not done because it causes problems. PS you assumed I’m a guy. I’m not but I do have 25+ years of dealing with contracts, vendors and projects. Half my life is spent trying to get suppliers to do things they may not want to do, and it all comes back to the paperwork particularly the disclaimers and exclusions. I can’t see any resolution for you.

The Colour palette that I have attached is only a ruff guide line... Are you painting the cupboards in a Dulux colour? What do the cupboards look like, for example the grain? I personally would look at a shade of green colour or blue. My examples might not be perfect as my monitor does not display colours well. What are you thinking for flooring and backsplash?

Your home renovation or design plans create an exciting time with lots to learn, see, decide and choose. Making the right choice of stone and it's use is paramount. Take the time to consider "living with the stone". Location - for the use of the stone will determine which stone to choose. It needs to be suitable for the purpose. Pavers / bench tops / bathrooms all need the right stone. Granite rather than marble is more suitable for kitchen benchtops and bathroom vanities as they are not as susceptible to etching and staining. Considerations: Will the stone be indoors or outdoors? Will the stone be used for functional or aesthetic purposes? Will the stone be in a kitchen, bathroom or foyer? Will the stone be in a wet area or dry area? Will the stone be exposed to constant foot traffic? Will the stone be exposed to acidic foods and liquids, cosmetics? Will the stone be exposed to hot pots? Will the stone be exposed to soap scum? Does the stone need to be slip resistant? https://themarbleman.com.au/tips-for-choosing-your-stone/ The Marble Man offers solid stone advise and we love to talk stone - 1300 627 626

Hi, Ali, I eventually went ahead and had the stone overlay on my kitchen benches and splashback. I am absolutely delighted with the result, and am so pleased I had it done. It has given a completely refurbished look to the kitchen; there was no collateral damage to the cupboards; no having to take the old tiles down from the existing splashback; I didn't change my cooktop or sink (just had the same ones put back in) and I couldn't be happier. The only benchtop which was completely replaced was the long one at the front. It was widened to make a breakfast bar. My previous benchtops were a dark mottled laminate and the splashback was cream subway tiles with a frieze. Very dated. I've attached a before and after photo (the timber venetians at the window have since been replaced with a white holland blind, which looks so much better. If you're in Sydney I can give you the name of the company that did it for me.