In context with you previous post, none of them. Sorry !

The wallpaper you have chosen is stunning and it is your hero- it is a very dominant feature. The light in you dining is lovely also. If you are definitely wanting pendants, perhaps a smaller version of your dining pendant to reference the dining area and pull it together? Or keep it simple with down lights.

I'm not sure any of them are right - but I think the second ones are the best of this lot - the top ones with stripes look like flying saucers coming in to land!!:)

If you want something of this scale - I would advise just one pendant. Remember that many of the lights don't throw much light especially those with opaque inners. If task lighting is important in this spot you may be better with something glass or a more horizontal profile. Try to emulate the shape of the backsplash tiles in some way.

None... i think you need to move away from the black and the green is too much.

Personally, none. But, if I had to choose one, it would be No. 3 because the timber top will help to hide dust. The two black ones will need to be dusted at least once a week to look nice. I'm not a fan of the green ones.

Number 1 picks up the white and black and I think that it could work with a tropical look as you describe the wall paper? I am assuming they will be a bit smaller than in the mock ups here.

HI,

Either picture one or two is good - Two seems bigger and one would be enough . Number one mirrors the wood then the black as in your kitchen and works well with the shape of your tiles but number to blends well and would give more light - I am leaning towards two.

I love the shape of number 1!

I love the first one in your real pics!

Very elegant

The first one in your real life or the third. If I had to pick one, it might be that the first will 'blend' better & then the focus is on the gorgeous splashback & wallpaper. The wire adds another feature.

AS the ceiling is low - [just noticed on your later pictures ]- i like the glass ones as suggested by Ninajub. the black could look heavy overhead unless it was a very short flex. Also need to think abut obscuring your vision. Worth considering a horizontal light- this one is from an nz site but worth thinking about - maybe can get the equivalent. http://www.lightingdirect.co.nz/shop/pendant-lights/Glass+Halogen/OTTO+3+LIGHT+PENDANT.

Hi Rachael

We would all like to see your final choice. I'm sure whatever you chose that it is going to be stunning, so please upload your photos once everything's done.

None as your ceilings seem too low. Would look great with just some LED downlights.

Have a look at 'black surface-mount down lights'. Perfect for your low ceiling and the hint of black works with your theme without being OTT.

We did a kitchen very similar to yours and went thru a similar dilemma last year. Ended up with a large sculptural drum pendant with a diffuser in the centre of kitchen and led recessed spots above island. Spots and drum are on two separate control switches with both fitted with dimmers. Led can be harsh if not able to be dimmed. Plastic on our new dishwasher went from blue to yellow overnight on first day and we had to ask for dimmer. Led great as task lighting but postion them so your head doesn't block light as you work. We play with lighting depending on whether we are working or relaxing. Money we saved on three pendants was spent on one drum.

Hello - I like option 3 - the timber top relates nicely to the timber in the kitchen