skip to main content

Building a Home Design Dilemma Renovating

Advise on ground floor extension layout

4 years ago

Hi, we're in the early stages of planning a double storey side and first floor rear extension to our traditional 1930s house. Our architect has drawn up some plans and whilst they do achieve most of what we are after, I'm not sure we're making the best use of the space.

I think my preferred plan is below but I'm worried that because of the door to the utility room, the allowed kitchen won't have enough cupboard or worktop space (I ideally want a bank of full height units for fridge and oven and not have the hob or sink on the island).

The architects answer was to extend further single storey out the back to give a longer run of units but this pushes us over our already tight budget and seems a mad use of money simply to provide space for a to access the utility room.

Any ideas for a better solution?

This is the existing house so you can see the difference.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

PRO
Studio Vonne
4 years ago
Hi Joanne, what will you mostly use the utility for? Will it be for washing machine and tumble dryer etc? Just thinking its a long route around if you want to take your washing upstairs. Do you actually need access through the kitchen? I know traditionally that's where it is but is it necessary in your case? Could you move the dividing wall to the right so there is access to the utility via the hallway, then have a very large island. Perhaps change the double doors to a single door and extend the worktop a bit further? Alternatively, could you keep access through the kitchen then divide the utility space so some of it can be used as a pantry - therefore needing less cupboard space in the kitchen?
PRO
OnePlan
4 years ago
Hi Joanne,
This is an exciting opportunity for you ! SV above, makes a great observation about the trek to the laundry. One other thing that also shouts out to me is the lack of soft seating to accommodate the 14 or so people you are expecting for dinner ? I think you’d benefit for a good session with your Architect, or maybe even consider bringing onboard another designer to thrash out the overall layout with you as part of the process . ( pretty much like what we do with clients ) then take the updated plans back to your Architect for their input on the new layout ?
There are some side and rear extended projects I think on our pro page if you want to look through some. Just click on my name or icon to get there !
Related Discussions
Floor plan/Downstairs layout help!
Q
Comments (15)
What is on the second floor?. Is this a slab on ground? Is the kitchen dining on a lower level, is this a built in verandah? Depending on if this is a slab on ground or raised off ground so that plumbing can easily be done, i would take out the laundry, just leave fireplace, maybe make that two way fireplace, wood or gas, and have dining here, which would open up that funny sitting room to this dining space and provide kids play area with build in window seats and the like. Does anyone really use formal dining now? build in the gap from sitting to front room, maybe even stealing a bit of space for storage. I would enclose that room next to entry to the study as most studies nowadays do not have to be massive spaces, unless clients are involved, that would make it quite place. With the storage space taken out for the dining play area, this would still be big enough for most. I would remove the existing study wall or at least open it up if structural to have the butlers pantry one side laundry the other with a gallery kitchen in front. Making the remainder the living space. Depending on budget i would raise the floor so that all this space is on one level. Depending on what the floor is or how many finishes you have i would make sure they are all the same. New timber floor, or new tiled floor, or carpet, what ever you like. If the terrace is then too low it might be able to be lifted simply to meet this new level. I would remove the hall cupboards to give more space to the living area and provide a wall with door if you like into the lounge room and guest suite from entry and then make the bedroom bathroom hall more private so that anyone staying will have a master suite, entry off entry, while family could still use the facilities. I think most people could cope with 3 entries off the entry, and the living door could be left open so that visually it can be seen as you enter the house, or if privacy is required, now that the hall cupboards are removed the entry to the living could be shifted down. If the laundry and garage were a bit bigger i would suggest a double garage, but they are too small. To keep the kitchen and dining in their current space would be one mistake after the other, unless you are overlooking some amazing views. Ros
...See More
Seeking advice on floor plan layout for kitchen, dine, study & lounge
Q
Comments (35)
I mentioned earlier to think about dropping the wall next to the stairs to hip or slightly higher height to allow for the TV, as this would further open up the top floor and perhaps show the street art, ie the framed print. I know that you don't want anything else hanging from the ceiling but because of the ceiling height you will need a reverse hanging fan to bring all the warm air down into the room that will sit up there if you don't. The heater is because you had one shown in your posted floor plan, this is one of the fires available on my 1997 CAD program, that's the colour it comes in but can be changed within the program cheers
...See More
Plans for extension - thoughts on floor plan?
Q
Comments (29)
retain the second living area, better resale value as more rooms and you will find it more useful the longer you stay. until the children are in primary school they will want to be in the same living room as you so they will play out in the back living area but over time you will be happy to have a separate play room full of toys you dont have to look at constantly while in the kitchen. I would definetely put both children in 1 room for at least 5 years then you will have another room that could become a third adult sitting/reading area. courtyards let in light and could almost become the second living room, or could turn out to look neglected with dead plants and somewhere you have to sweep up all the time its windy?
...See More
Extension/Renovation ideas needed
Q
Comments (4)
pending more details my suggestion would be to have a bigger kitchen with pantry as the dining area feels too cramped, use the old dining as a separate study bed 4 with two living areas and consider a future master suite extension instead of rearranging the existing living area.. when you have such a good sized block of land extending at ground level is far more cost effective than a second storey that uses so much space with stairs and, as big reader has already suggested it's cost effective to have plans drawn up and r Development applications submitted for both extensions and the alfresco even if you don't complete them all at the same time...btw having the new northern kitchen wall line up with the northern wall of the original master bedroom would make the roof work better and not needing to make space for the dining area on the west gives more flexibility with the size of the kitchen family room
...See More
Joanne B
Original Author
4 years ago
Thanks for the comments

@studiovonne - yes the utility will house washing machine, boiler, cleaning stuff, bulk buys etc. it doesn't need to be accessed from the kitchen by any means but if we move the wall as you suggested it is almost back to its existing position and couldn't justify the cost of moving it such a small amount. We wanted to move the wall because otherwise it is a huge utility room (currently the size of our kitchen which isn't a bad size just not the open plan space we want).

@oneplan - I'd like to get some other input to the layout but we have chosen an architect that was quite expensive with the feeling that he would come up with some clever ideas to solve the issues to get what we want but so far that doesn't seem to be happening!

I'm currently playing with having a dog leg into the hallway to allow access from the hall way but without losing all the space in the kitchen area or even having a diagonal wall from the utility door in the hall to the door into the kitchen but I just cant come up with a kitchen layout that gives me everything I want!
PRO
Lees Munday Architects
4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

So many lost opportunities:

Click on the image to expand

1) the long extension is blocked by the office. Far more dramatic if the full length and outlook and light at both ends can be used.

2) The kitchen is contrived but doesn't work, as you say.

3) A powerful symmetry can be gained in all aspects of the kitchen/dining/slobbing seating area.

4) space for a big bookshelf/tv wall in the casual seating area

5) space for coat hanging in the hall and utility (none in the original)

6) Kitchen and dining are interchangeable depending on preference.

7) a less space wasting office with direct access to the garden. Could alternatively be a kids room for the avalanche of plastic.

8) Significantly less expensive because the wall is kept, but the chimney is removed in this floor.

9) I would use sliding doors at the ends. Minimal frame type with just 2 panels. Bi folds are really ugly when closed (most of the time).

10) you could extend the kitchen worktop outside as an outdoor kitchen.

I did this out of personal interest because I could see lost opportunities and it bugged me so I had to solve it. But if you want help or just to discuss, please get in touch. Leesmunday.com

Underground house · More Info

Merchants House · More Info
Joanne B
Original Author
4 years ago
@leesmunday thanks for your comments. Funnily enough we had lots of the similar thoughts and so have a revised plan now.

We have had to leave the kitchen where it is as we want space to extend the dining table let to seat 20+ and otherwise the island is in the way so we're just going to have to be clever with the layout.

Sponsored

More Discussions

Ideas for window treatment

18

Tiny living area help

17

Ensuite / bed / WIR layout help?

16

Best layout for this laundry

11

13